Right on the water in Shelter Island village, we serve locally caught seafood the way it should be — simple, honest, and unforgettable.
Commander Cody's sits right in the heart of Shelter Island village, just steps from the ferry dock. We've been serving this community fresh, honest seafood for years — the kind of place where regulars know your name and your order.
Our fish comes from local boats that pull in every morning. We keep the menu straightforward because the catch speaks for itself. Whether it's a quick lunch between ferry rides or a relaxed dinner with the family, we want you to leave satisfied and coming back.
41
Smith Street
Daily
Fresh Catch
🚢
Near the Ferry
Our daily specials change with the catch and the season. These are the dishes we're most excited about right now — ask us how they're prepared.
Whatever the boats brought in — prepared simply, always perfectly cooked.
Local oysters, shucked fresh, served with mignonette and cocktail sauce.
Local greens, farm vegetables, house vinaigrette — light and refreshing.
Specials vary by day and availability. Call ahead or visit us to see what's cooking.
Open 7 Days a Week
Ferry hours apply — call for details
Hours may vary during off-season. Call ahead.
Walk-ins are always welcome. Or give us a call and we'll have your order ready when you arrive.
